Journal

When to Throw Away an Intimate Object: Signs, Material by Material

Quand jeter un objet intime : les signes, matière par matière

Most of us keep an intimate object the way we keep an old pair of shoes — long after it has stopped being right, because throwing it out feels like admitting something. Yet when to throw away an intimate object is one of the plainest questions in intimate care, and it has a plainer answer than most people expect.

This guide is about the day an object stops being safe to keep — what wear looks like in glass, steel and silicone, why a damaged surface matters for cleaning, and how to let go without ceremony or guilt.

Letting Go Is Part of the Care

A drawer of objects can hold a quiet pressure. Each one cost something, each one was chosen with a little hope, and none of them feels like it has earned the trash can. So they stay, rarely used and half forgotten, and the one you actually reach for is the one with the hairline crack.

The piece on inspecting, washing and storing glass already says that a cracked piece is retired without negotiation. This page extends that rule to every common material — glass, steel, silicone and the softer elastomers. The test stays the same each time — an object stays if you can still clean it properly and still trust its surface against your skin. If either one fails, it has done its work.

Nothing here is a schedule — the guides consulted for this page give no lifespan in months or years for these objects, so none is invented here. What they give is signs, and signs serve you better than dates because they describe your own object rather than an average one.

How many objects in your drawer do you actually reach for?

Glass and Steel: What Damage Looks Like

For glass, the public health advice is a habit of looking. A guide to sex toys from the Canadian Public Health Association, reprinted by CATIE in 2010, says glass should be checked in bright light occasionally for little cracks or chips. The UBC Wellness Centre, in a guide updated in March 2026, tells readers to check for rough seams, cracks or tears before using an object, because a damaged one can hold bacteria or cause harm.

Steel is tougher but not immortal. An article on instrument care in Outpatient Surgery, a publication of AORN, describes pitting, minuscule pits that penetrate the surface, and says that because corrosion gives bacteria an unreachable hiding place, pitted instruments must be discarded. That is a surgical standard, written for instruments, so read it as the strict end of the range — it still tells you what to look for on a steel object — pits rather than marks. The piece on 316L stainless steel explains why this alloy is chosen in the first place.

The same article separates real damage from surface deposits. Staining, a discolouration left by inadequate soil removal, can come off with effort or a soak. Water spots wipe away with minimal friction. A simple test follows — if a mark wipes away, it was a deposit. If your fingernail catches in it, it is part of the surface.

When did you last look at your glass or steel piece under a strong light?

Silicone and Softer Materials: Nicks, Tackiness, Folds

Silicone wears differently from glass, and its wear is easier to miss. The same Canadian Public Health Association guide advises checking silicone objects for nicks or cuts that can occur over time and can trap bacteria and viruses. Respect Inc., a Queensland sex worker organization, adds that silicone objects with folds or ridges can grow mould if they are not dried properly.

Lubricant can also be the cause. Respect Inc. warns that silicone lubes can melt silicone, and that on jelly objects a silicone lube can cause them to disintegrate — if an object has gone tacky or soft after a silicone glide, you are probably looking at the pairing described in silicone on silicone and oil on latex, and the kind thing to do is retire that object.

The softer the material, the more it asks of you — the UBC guide notes that elastomer is soft and porous, so it should be washed often because it can hold onto bacteria. The Canadian Public Health Association guide says jelly can get sticky and pick up lint and dust, and that plastic can get brittle over time. None of this is a reason for alarm — it is a reason to look at these materials more often than you look at glass.

Which of your objects has a fold, a seam or a ridge that you never really see dry?

Why a Worn Surface Is a Cleaning Problem

Porosity is covered in the piece on porous and non-porous materials. Wear creates a small version of the same problem. A pit, a nick or a crack is a place where soap and a cloth may not reach, and the sources above say the same thing in different words — damage can hide what you can no longer wash out.

The laboratory picture is more nuanced than the slogan. A 2009 study in the Journal of Biomedical Materials Research, using silicone cast with different roughness and Staphylococcus epidermidis, found that roughness significantly affected bacterial adhesion and colonization only when it was above about 200 nanometres, and that hydrophobicity played a major role too. That is a scale far finer than any eye or fingertip can read, and it was a lab test on silicone samples — so it says little about your drawer.

So the working rule stays practical, and it matches what Brown University's BWell service says — if cleaning an object properly feels too time-consuming or unrealistic, think about a different one. An object you cannot get smooth and clean has stopped doing its job, whatever it cost.

Is there an object you avoid cleaning because you already know it won't come clean?

Letting Go Without a Ceremony

None of the guides consulted gives a finished list of reasons to retire an object — so here is a working one, labelled as common sense rather than a standard. Out it goes if it is cracked, chipped, pitted, nicked or cut, if it has turned tacky or soft, or if you cannot get it clean. Wrap it, throw it out, and do not pass it on — a worn object is not a gift.

A smaller set that you inspect is safer than a large one you never look at. If you keep a few objects, you can give each one the kind of attention described above, and you will notice the day one of them changes. Keeping glass away from metal in storage is part of the same habit.

Retiring an object is not a prompt to replace it — sometimes the honest answer is to stop and own fewer things. A good setup is built from a few objects you trust rather than from a collection.

Which object would you take out tomorrow, if you dared?

Educational text, not medical advice

Pain, bleeding, burning or irritation after using an object, or a crack you discover afterwards: stop, do not reuse it, and speak with a health professional if symptoms persist.

If you could keep only the objects you truly trust, which ones would be left?

← Browse more articles

This article is educational and is not medical advice. It does not replace the manufacturer's instructions or a healthcare professional's opinion. If you have a persistent symptom or any doubt about an object, please speak with a healthcare professional.

←